Five artificial intelligences are challenged to read like humans: the winner was not ChatGPT

Five artificial intelligences are challenged to read like humans: the winner was not ChatGPT
Which artificial intelligence bot understands texts better?

Most read in Argentina

Meta introduced 'Muse Ember': how its new economic AI model works

  1. Blizzard confirmed that 'World of Warcraft Forever' surpassed all previous launches

  2. Fixed term: which bank offers the highest rate in November 2026

  3. Holiday on Wednesday, November 11: where there will be a day off for the visit of Pope Leo XIV

  4. Mauricio Pochettino is among the candidates to replace Michael Carrick at Manchester United

Imagen de Editorial Team
porEditorial Team
Argentina

The Washington Post tested five AIs with real texts. Only one was consistent and outperformed the others in all areas

Add La Derecha Diario on
Share:


La Derecha Diario on X

  1. “EN VEZ DE HABLAR DE CUÁL ES SU PROPUESTA PARA LOS ESPAÑOLES, ESTÁ HABLANDO DE LAS ENTREVISTAS QUE ME VAN A HACER A MÍ” El candidato derechista de VOX, Santiago Abascal, estalló contra el corrupto Pedro Sánchez por intentar censurarlo. “A nosotros nos gusta poder hablar en libertad”.

    9 min ago

  2. URGENTE — EL RÉGIMEN DE IRÁN DECLARÓ TERRORISTAS A LA ARMADA Y A LA FUERZA AÉREA ARGENTINA La dictadura terrorista islámica iraní anunció la medida en represalia por la decisión del Gobierno de Javier Milei de declarar organización terrorista a la Guardia Revolucionaria de Irán, el brazo terrorista del régimen.

    12 min ago

  3. EMOTIVO MOMENTO: El Papa León XIV bendijo a varios bebés durante su recorrido en el papamóvil en la vigilia de jóvenes celebrada en Palermo.

    19 min ago

  4. LACRAS: Manifestantes de extrema izquierda vandalizaron las vidrieras de empresas y comercios en Barcelona durante la jornada de protestas y disturbios convocada como “huelga general”.

    29 min ago

  5. AHORA — Una multitud de fieles se congregó en Devoto a la espera de la llegada del Papa León XIV, en el último día de la visita del Santo Padre a la Argentina.

    39 min ago

La Derecha Diario logo
TwitterInstagramYouTubeTikTokFacebook
Derecha Diario TV

Nosotros

  • Quienes Somos
  • Autores
  • Donar

Privacidad

  • Protección de datos
  • Canales
  • Sitemap
  • RSS

Contacto

  • info@derechadiario.com.ar
PUBLICIDAD
La Derecha Diario logo
ESX logoInstagram logoYouTube logoTikTok logoFacebook
ARGENTINAUNITED STATESECUADORISRAELMEXICOURUGUAY
ARGENTINAUNITED STATESECUADORISRAELMEXICOURUGUAY
DERECHA DIARIO TV
  • ES
    XInstagramYouTubeTikTokFacebook
  • DERECHA DIARIO TV
  • Sections
  • ARGENTINA
  • UNITED STATES
  • ECUADOR
  • ISRAEL
  • MEXICO
  • URUGUAY
  • Countries
  • La Derecha Diario logoLA DERECHA DIARIO
  • La Derecha Diario México logoLA DERECHA DIARIO MÉXICO
  • La Derecha Diario Uruguay logoLA DERECHA DIARIO URUGUAY
  • La Derecha Diario Ecuador logoLA DERECHA DIARIO ECUADOR
  • La Derecha Diario Israel logoLA DERECHA DIARIO ISRAEL
  • La Derecha Diario Estados Unidos logoLA DERECHA DIARIO ESTADOS UNIDOS
  • Topics
  • GUERRA EN IRÁN
  • The Newspaper
  • QUIENES SOMOS
  • AUTORES
  • PUBLICIDAD
  • DONAR

Related news

Mourning in Argentine football: Carlos Babington, one of Huracán's greatest idols, has passed away at the age of 77

Mourning in Argentine football: Carlos Babington, one of Huracán's greatest idols, has passed away at the age of 77

The president of Lanús anticipated when the game against River would be played and explained his position on the playoffs

The president of Lanús anticipated when the game against River would be played and explained his position on the playoffs

Pope Leo XIV held a mass for more than two million people in Luján

Pope Leo XIV held a mass for more than two million people in Luján

Fausto Vera and his future in River: why his continuity depends on Kevin Castaño

Fausto Vera and his future in River: why his continuity depends on Kevin Castaño

Argentina closed its arguments against the United Kingdom before the International Tribunal for the Law of the Sea and awaits a ruling on the Falklands

Argentina closed its arguments against the United Kingdom before the International Tribunal for the Law of the Sea and awaits a ruling on the Falklands

Diego Placente revealed the list of call-ups for the Argentina National Team for the U-17 World Cup in Qatar

Diego Placente revealed the list of call-ups for the Argentina National Team for the U-17 World Cup in Qatar

Medical research: high performance

All five bots showed an acceptable level when reading scientific papers, perhaps because studies have predictable structures and human-written summaries.

Anthropic lanzó su nueva familia de modelos de inteligencia artificial
Anthropic lanzó su nueva familia de modelos de inteligencia artificial

Claude received the highest score (10/10) for explaining a paper on long COVID. It was clear, technical, and useful for doctors. In contrast, Gemini left out essential parts of the study on Parkinson's.

Politics: ChatGPT understood Trump better

Donald Trump's speeches were the biggest challenge in terms of critical analysis. ChatGPT achieved the best balance between context and accuracy.

Estados Unidos planea redoblar las exportaciones de armas del primer mandato de Trump
Estados Unidos planea redoblar las exportaciones de armas del primer mandato de Trump

Copilot, although technically correct, didn't capture the tone of the speeches.

Claude was the most consistent and took first place

Overall, Claude achieved the best performance. It was the only one that stood out in both scientific analysis and legal writing, and it maintained consistent responses.

Unlike other bots that summarized poorly or ignored key parts, Claude proved to be more complete and accurate. According to the judges, it came closest to being a good real assistant.

En el balance general, Claude logró el mejor desempeño
En el balance general, Claude logró el mejor desempeño

Can we trust these bots to read for us?

Claude and ChatGPT proved to be the most capable, but no bot exceeded 70% overall accuracy. All of them, to a greater or lesser extent, omitted key data or caused misleading answers.

While they can be useful as reading assistants, they still don't replace human comprehension. Many times, it's clear that "the robot hides behind a human mask."

How well can a chatbot understand what it reads? To find out, a team from the Washington Post tested five of the leading AI bots on the market.

They analyzed everything from novels and scientific papers to political speeches and legal contracts. The results brought surprises among the world's most widely used virtual assistants.

Las decisiones clave seguirán necesitando la aprobación humana
Las decisiones clave seguirán necesitando la aprobación humana

Can AI really understand what it reads?

AI bots promise to be reading superpowers: they summarize contracts, books, or research just by uploading a file. But do they really understand what they're reading, or are they just imitating comprehension?

To answer that question, the Washington Post organized a test with the five most popular chatbots: ChatGPT, Claude, Copilot, Meta AI, and Gemini.

  • Four types of text were used: literature, medical science, legal contracts, and political speeches.
  • The texts were evaluated by experts in each field.
  • They formulated 115 questions to analyze comprehension, critical analysis, and accuracy.

Los riesgos del desarrollo acelerado de la IA
Los riesgos del desarrollo acelerado de la IA

Literature: many failed when reading a historical novel

In the literary area, the bots performed poorly. Only Claude got all the key facts from the book right, while ChatGPT provided the best overall summary, although it omitted characters and themes such as slavery.

Gemini was the worst. The book's author compared it to the "Seinfeld" character who watched the movie instead of reading the novel.

ChatGPT hizo el mejor resumen general
ChatGPT hizo el mejor resumen general

Legal contracts: Claude stood out again

According to Sterling Miller, a corporate lawyer, Claude was the only one who understood the most important clauses well. It even proposed useful improvements and detected details that other bots ignored.

Meanwhile, ChatGPT and Meta AI summarized key parts in a single line, something Miller described as "useless."