Argentina is once again discussing its electoral rules. The government is pushing for a reform whose latest draft would suspend the primaries (PASO) until 2027, while the Senate begins negotiations on the project this week. The immediate discussion revolves around cost, candidacies, and electoral convenience. But mandatory primaries allow us to raise a prior question: when we participate in an election, are we really accepting that the winner has the right to govern us?
This was the topic I returned to “discuss” with Murray Rothbard. Because his critique does not focus on what the best electoral system is, but on something more fundamental: what can a vote really demonstrate about the consent of the voter.
—Professor Rothbard, in Argentina we are once again discussing the PASO. What problem do you find with mandatory primaries?
—First, I would distinguish two issues. One is how the state organizes its elections. The other, much deeper, is why we assume that participating in them equates to consenting to the resulting political power.
—But those who vote are accepting the rules of the game.
—Not necessarily. In “Man, Economy, and State with Power and Market,” I pointed out that the voter only demonstrates a relative preference for one candidate over other possible rulers. They do so within a system where, whether they vote or not, one of them will govern over them.
—So, if I vote for candidate A, what am I saying?
—That given the available alternatives, you prefer A over B. Nothing more. It does not logically follow that you have authorized all the taxes, regulations, or prohibitions that A may impose on you.
—And what about someone who decides not to vote?
—They also do not escape the decisions of the winner. That is precisely the difference with a voluntary association: you can refuse to participate and leave the relationship. In front of the state, abstaining from choosing a ruler does not mean being outside of its jurisdiction.
—But we need some way to decide who governs. Is it not preferable to vote than to have power imposed without elections?








