Three people pose together outdoors, two adults are smiling, and one of them is holding a baby with a blurred face. — A Pennsylvania prosecutor requests the removal of custody from a gay couple convicted of sexual abuse of a minor and possession of child pornography | La Derecha Diario

Camara — A Pennsylvania prosecutor requests the removal of custody from a gay couple convicted of sexual abuse of a minor and possession of child pornography | La Derecha Diario

The state of Pennsylvania requests the removal of custody of a baby from a sex offender

The case, which caused great discontent in American society, involves the adoption of a baby through surrogacy by a gay couple convicted of sexual abuse

02/08/2025 13:10:00h

Editorial Team

A York County, Pennsylvania, prosecutor is urging state lawmakers to close a legal loophole that allowed Brandon Riley-Mitchell, a registered sex offender, to become a parent through surrogacy.

The controversy erupted after a video went viral showing Riley-Mitchell, 39 years old, and his husband, Logan Steven Riley, celebrating their son Atticus's first birthday, which sparked outrage among conservative sectors after Riley-Mitchell's 2016 conviction for child sexual abuse and possession of child pornography.

The couple raised more than $2,000 through a GoFundMe campaign to finance their parenthood process through gestational surrogacy, a method in which an embryo, created via in vitro fertilization with an anonymous donor's egg, is carried by a surrogate mother with no biological link to the child.

Short-haired man with a light beard wearing a blue t-jersey in front of a gray wall

Brandon Keith Riley-Mitchell pleaded guilty to child sexual abuse and possession of child pornography | La Derecha Diario

The individuals took advantage of a legal loophole.

The campaign, which was archived, did not mention Riley-Mitchell's criminal record, which includes inappropriate electronic communications with a minor between 16 and 18 years old and possession of more than 12,000 sexually explicit text messages with the victim between 2013 and 2014.

York County prosecutor Tim Barker expressed his concern about the lack of oversight in surrogacy agreements compared to adoption processes, which require rigorous scrutiny.

"I deeply appreciate the concern and outrage expressed by many regarding the legal loophole that allows a registered sex offender to become a parent through surrogacy without the same scrutiny, accountability, and judicial oversight required in the adoption process," he commented.

A man in a suit speaks at a press conference alongside two uniformed police officers and another man in the background.

The York County prosecutor expressed concern about the lack of regulation in these cases | La Derecha Diario

Society demands that custody be taken away from the offender.

Barker explained that Pennsylvania law currently doesn't prohibit a registered sex offender from becoming a parent through surrogacy, which leaves his office without legal grounds to intervene unless a criminal violation occurs.

The prosecutorial authority trusts that state lawmakers will seek "constitutionally permissible legislative actions" to protect children and called for a review of the issue.

The public reaction has been intense, with more than 3,000 people signing an online petition launched Tuesday to demand that the child be removed from the couple's home, calling for sex offender Riley-Mitchell to be stripped of custody of the child.

Document with the word subrogation on a table next to a judge's gavel, a book, and a fountain pen

At the moment, there is no legislation preventing surrogacy for individuals with prior convictions | La Derecha Diario

The crimes for which Riley-Mitchell was convicted.

Riley-Mitchell, a former high school teacher, pleaded guilty in 2016 to possession of child pornography, receiving a sentence of three to 23 months in prison and orders to surrender his teaching credentials and avoid unsupervised contact with minors.

He completed his probation in 2021 and now works at a pharmaceutical company in Lancaster, according to his LinkedIn profile.

The case has sparked a broader debate about surrogacy regulation in Pennsylvania, with advocates and officials calling for reforms to ensure child safety, while addressing complex legal and ethical issues regarding parenthood and criminal records.

➡️ Argentina