The State promises you rights while taking away your freedom.

The State promises you rights while taking away your freedom.
The State promises you rights while taking away your freedom.

Most read in Argentina

With tributes, dedications and a lot of emotion, Tenerife returned to play after the death of Jesús de Miguel

  1. The Justice declared the pension formula of Kirchnerism unconstitutional and acknowledged a loss of almost 50%

  2. England defeated Spain 3-2, ending their impressive unbeaten streak of 43 matches

  3. South Korea asked Xi Jinping's regime to help resume dialogue with North Korea

  4. Students and citizens of Haiti thank Bukele for the military deployment from El Salvador

Imagen de Editorial Team
porEditorial Team
Argentina

Freedom weakens when the State turns needs into obligations on others.

Add La Derecha Diario on
Share:

For much of the 20th century, politics stopped discussing how to protect people's freedom and began to focus on another, much more ambitious idea: guaranteeing material outcomes. From there, the concept of "right" began to expand almost infinitely.

First came the so-called social rights. Then came new generations of rights linked to well-being, happiness, the environment, guaranteed access to goods and services, and even increasingly broad demands on the State. The problem is that behind that morally appealing language, there exists a much deeper discussion that is rarely raised openly.

Can there be a right that compels another person to work to satisfy it?

Here appears a central difference that modern public debate tends to ignore: the distinction between negative rights and positive rights.

Negative rights are those that require others not to interfere. The right not to be robbed, censored, beaten, or arbitrarily imprisoned. They are rights compatible with individual freedom because they do not require appropriating someone else's work. They simply imply that no one interferes with another.

Positive rights work differently. When someone claims to have a "right" to receive housing, health care, education, or certain material goods, an obligation on third parties necessarily arises. Because those resources do not appear on their own. They must be financed, produced, and sustained by someone.

And that is where one of the great contradictions of modern States begins.

In the name of expanding rights, the coercive power of the State over those who produce, work, invest, or generate wealth often ends up being expanded. What is presented as institutionalized solidarity ends up depending on increasingly high taxes, more invasive regulations, and a permanent transfer of resources managed by politics.

For decades, Argentina took that logic to the extreme.

The country built a political culture where practically everything came to be considered a right guaranteed by the State. Subsidies, artificial prices, expansive public employment, permanent assistance, economic controls, and a growing bureaucratic machinery financed by tax pressure, inflation, and debt.

The result was not a freer or more prosperous society. It was exactly the opposite.

As the State promised more things, it also needed to appropriate more resources. And the more that dynamic advanced, the less autonomy individuals retained. The citizen ceased to be someone responsible for building their own life project and became a subject dependent on political decisions.

That is why the underlying discussion is not only economic. It is moral and institutional.

Every concrete freedom needs a material base. The freedom to undertake, for example, does not exist merely as a principle written in a Constitution. It requires capital, inputs, energy, credit, access to markets, and the ability to produce without arbitrary obstacles. When political power controls those resources or conditions access to them through regulations, permits, controls, or bureaucratic discretion, it can limit economic freedom even without formally prohibiting private activity.

Argentina offers numerous examples of that logic. Companies that could legally exist but could not import inputs, access dollars, remit profits, or sustain their operations due to regulatory and fiscal pressure. The result was an economy where production depended less on entrepreneurial capacity and more on the relationship with political power.

Modern interventionism often does not need to nationalize or prohibit. It is enough to control the material conditions that make private activity possible.

That is why private property is not simply an economic issue. It also serves as a limit to political power. Where individuals retain economic autonomy, there is greater room to dissent, criticize, and act independently of the State.

The management of Javier Milei is perhaps reopening, for the first time in decades, this discussion head-on in Argentina. Not only around the deficit or public spending but about the very size of the State and the relationship between freedom, individual responsibility, and political power.

The deepest cultural change does not only involve ordering fiscal accounts. It involves asking again what a right really means and how far the State can expand without ultimately eroding the freedoms it claims to protect.

Because when everything becomes a politically guaranteed right, someone always ends up paying the cost. And the more things power promises, the more resources it needs to extract from society to sustain them.

Freedom then ceases to be individual autonomy and comes to depend on permits, subsidies, and structures managed from above.

That may be one of the great ideological debates of the coming years: whether societies will continue to indefinitely expand the obligations of the State or whether they will return to placing limits on political power to regain spaces of responsibility, property, and individual freedom.


La Derecha Diario on X

  1. KICILLOF ABANDONÓ UNA OBRA HIDRÁULICA Y SAN NICOLÁS SUFRE LAS INUNDACIONES: Vecinos denunciaron que el inútil gobernador mantiene paralizada desde hace años una obra iniciada que ya tenía más del 90% de avance. Solo falta la conexión que permitiría desagotar el agua, mientras la Provincia sigue sin responder a los ofrecimientos del municipio para terminarla.

    4 min ago

  2. PELÍCULA DE TERROR EN LA VIDA REAL: RESCATARON A 16 NIÑOS ENCERRADOS DURANTE AÑOS EN UNA CASA DEL HORROR La Policía de Ohio descubrió a 16 hermanos, de entre 1 y 18 años, que habían pasado gran parte de los últimos cuatro años confinados en una habitación de apenas 3,6 × 3,6 metros, rodeados de excrementos, insectos y basura. Ninguno asistía a la escuela, algunos ni siquiera podían hablar y la mayor de las víctimas no sabía escribir su propio nombre. Siete de los menores tuvieron que ser hospitalizados, dos fueron trasladados en helicóptero y uno se encontraba en estado crítico. La situación era tan aberrante que el fiscal general de Ohio advirtió que, si la Policía hubiera tardado apenas 24 horas más en intervenir, existía una alta probabilidad de encontrar a uno o varios niños muertos. Los padres, Gary y Elizabeth Siders, fueron acusados de 19 cargos cada uno por poner en peligro a menores, incluyendo delitos graves relacionados con daños físicos. Ambos enfrentan también cuatro cargos cada uno por delitos sexuales contra otro menor de entre 13 y 15 años: dos por agresión sexual y dos por violación. La abuela fue acusada de otros 19 cargos por poner en peligro a los niños y declarada incapaz de afrontar el juicio, mientras que los 16 cargos contra el abuelo fueron desestimados después de que la Justicia determinara que no estaba en condiciones de ser juzgado. La madre, nuevamente embarazada, fue declarada apta para enfrentar el proceso judicial.

    14 min ago

  3. FLÁVIO BOLSONARO ADVIRTIÓ SOBRE EL AVANCE DEL TERRORISMO EN AMÉRICA: "La única posibilidad que veo es tener un presidente de Estados Unidos que sea republicano, que sea de derecha, que tenga esa conciencia y priorice este tema". El perseguido líder opositor brasileño repudió a los gobiernos de izquierda por su complicidad con los grupos terroristas y pidió que los republicanos permanezcan en la Casa Blanca para evitar que estas organizaciones se fortalezcan y avancen en la región.

    29 min ago

  4. EEUU EN ALERTA POR UN PLAN IRANÍ PARA MATAR A TRUMP: La inteligencia israelí advirtió sobre un atentado con drones explosivos contra el presidente y altos funcionarios estadounidenses. El secretario de Seguridad Nacional, Markwayne Mullin, aseguró que están preparados ante las amenazas. "Estamos bien preparados. Dentro de Estados Unidos vigilamos esto todos los días. La seguridad del presidente, de su familia y del público es nuestra principal preocupación".

    44 min ago

  5. BASURA MISERABLE: A semanas de la muerte de 69 personas en la tragedia ferroviaria de Toledo, el corrupto Pedro Sánchez baila en un acto de campaña del PSOE mientras intenta sostenerse en el poder a toda costa.

    59 min ago

La Derecha Diario logo
TwitterInstagramYouTubeTikTokFacebook
Derecha Diario TV

Nosotros

  • Quienes Somos
  • Autores
  • Donar

Privacidad

  • Protección de datos
  • Canales
  • Sitemap
  • RSS

Contacto

  • info@derechadiario.com.ar
PUBLICIDAD
La Derecha Diario logo
ESX logoInstagram logoYouTube logoTikTok logoFacebook
ARGENTINAUNITED STATESECUADORISRAELMEXICOURUGUAY
ARGENTINAUNITED STATESECUADORISRAELMEXICOURUGUAY
DERECHA DIARIO TV
  • ES
    XInstagramYouTubeTikTokFacebook
  • DERECHA DIARIO TV
  • Sections
  • ARGENTINA
  • UNITED STATES
  • ECUADOR
  • ISRAEL
  • MEXICO
  • URUGUAY
  • Countries
  • La Derecha Diario logoLA DERECHA DIARIO
  • La Derecha Diario México logoLA DERECHA DIARIO MÉXICO
  • La Derecha Diario Uruguay logoLA DERECHA DIARIO URUGUAY
  • La Derecha Diario Ecuador logoLA DERECHA DIARIO ECUADOR
  • La Derecha Diario Israel logoLA DERECHA DIARIO ISRAEL
  • La Derecha Diario Estados Unidos logoLA DERECHA DIARIO ESTADOS UNIDOS
  • The Newspaper
  • QUIENES SOMOS
  • AUTORES
  • PUBLICIDAD
  • DONAR

Related news

GTA 6: the official soundtrack list has leaked just days before the video game's release

GTA 6: the official soundtrack list has leaked just days before the video game's release

Worlds 2026: how many millions of dollars were distributed in the League of Legends World Championship

Worlds 2026: how many millions of dollars were distributed in the League of Legends World Championship

Gemini connects with Google Wallet to analyze expenses and detect subscriptions

Gemini connects with Google Wallet to analyze expenses and detect subscriptions

Tesla opened registration for its first customers in Argentina

Tesla opened registration for its first customers in Argentina

Toyota unveiled a preview of the new Hilux: what changes the pickup will have

Toyota unveiled a preview of the new Hilux: what changes the pickup will have

Ranking of virtual wallets: which pay the most interest this week

Ranking of virtual wallets: which pay the most interest this week