Former UNAM rector fined for plagiarism case in Yasmín Esquivel's thesis

The justice system has issued a significant ruling in the prolonged case of alleged plagiarism. This case involves Yasmín Esquivel Mossa, current minister of the Supreme Court of Justice of the Nation and candidate for reelection in 2025.

A judge in Mexico City has sentenced Enrique Graue, former rector of the National Autonomous University of Mexico (UNAM), and Fernando Macedo Chagolla, former director of FES Aragón, to pay compensation. The amount is 15 million pesos (approximately 33 million dollars) to Martha Rodríguez Ortiz, who served as Esquivel's thesis advisor.

Judicial process and sentence

After an exhaustive judicial process, the judge concluded that both Graue and Macedo committed acts that harmed the honor and reputation of Rodríguez Ortiz. Attributing the responsibility for the plagiarism, which according to the judge, was without conclusive evidence.

Additionally, the judge argued the vulnerability of Rodríguez Ortiz, a 70-year-old academic, whose situation required special protection.

Impact and legal precedents

Esquivel has denied on multiple occasions any wrongdoing related to her thesis. The minister even attempted to block additional ethical investigations by UNAM on this matter.

This judicial ruling sets an important precedent for Mexican academic institutions. It establishes criteria on how accusations of academic integrity will be handled.

Implications for Esquivel's career

This controversial incident will remain a crucial aspect of Esquivel's career. It will affect not only her professional trajectory but also the public perception of Mexican justice. The controversy highlights the need for greater transparency in the national academic field.

The case has caused a intense debate on academic ethics in Mexican institutions. It underscores the importance of having robust systems that protect intellectual integrity.